Buffalo

6 Places to Get Top-Notch Mac & Cheese in WNY

These Buffalo Chefs Have Mastered a Classic

Seth Greene

Seth Greene

Oct 14, 2026

0 Comments

In Buffalo, mac n cheese is not just a side dish; it can be the reason to choose a restaurant.

 

Whether you crave a bubbling baked mac n cheese or a spicy Buffalo mac n cheese, these local spots offer different ways to enjoy a familiar favorite.

 

Mooney’s Sports Bar & Grill makes the case for going all in, with baked versions inspired by Buffalo favorites such as beef on weck and stuffed banana peppers.

 

Its Tonawanda, Depew and Kenmore locations give diners across the area a chance to explore a menu that goes well beyond the basic bowl.

 

For a less elaborate order, Ballyhoo on South Park Avenue serves mac n cheese as a side that deserves attention of its own.

 

Sometimes the comforting choice is the one without a pile of toppings.

 

Barbecue fans can head toward Fat Bob’s Smokehouse, where macaroni and cheese fits naturally beside smoky meats and has also appeared in heartier, topped versions.

 

A Buffalo chicken variation is worth considering if you want a little heat with your cheese.

 

At The Place on Lexington Avenue, options have included pork belly, lobster and truffle mushroom alongside a traditional version.

 

That range makes mac n cheese feel less like an afterthought and more like the main event.

 

Outside the city, Griffon Gastropub has served shells in smoked gouda sauce beneath a buttery cracker topping, a combination built for anyone who prizes texture.

 

Its locations in Lewiston, East Aurora and Niagara Falls make it an option for a comfort-food stop farther afield.

 

The Delaware Pub & Grill in Tonawanda offers another smoked gouda take, pairing spiral pasta with tomatoes and a breadcrumb topping.

 

Chicken, bacon or andouille sausage can turn that dish into a more substantial meal.

 

Menus can change, so check what is available before making a special trip.

 

Still, Buffalo diners have plenty of reasons to keep looking for their favorite forkful, from crisp baked toppings to rich, creamy sauce.

0 Comments

Join the conversation

Be the first to comment

Share your thoughts above.

WNY Insider

© 2026 WNY Insider.

WNY Insider is your playful, punchy guide to everything happening in and around Buffalo, NY. From cool local events to neighborhood stories, we shine a spotlight on the people and places that make Western New York a standout community.

© 2026 WNY Insider.